Why do polar and nonpolar substances dissolve differently?
Polar and nonpolar substances dissolve differently because their solubility depends on the types of intermolecular forces they can form with the solvent. The rule “like dissolves like” captures the idea: polar substances dissolve well in polar solvents, and nonpolar substances dissolve well in nonpolar solvents. This happens because dissolving requires the solute–solvent attractions to replace the original solute–solute and solvent–solvent attractions. If the new interactions are not strong enough, dissolving becomes energetically unfavorable.
Polar substances have uneven charge distribution, giving them partial positive and negative ends. When placed in a polar solvent like water, these partial charges attract the solvent molecules through dipole–dipole interactions or hydrogen bonding. For example, when salt dissolves, the ions separate and become surrounded by water molecules whose partial charges stabilize them. This strong solute–solvent attraction compensates for the energy required to break the ionic lattice.
Nonpolar substances lack permanent dipoles. Their only interactions are dispersion forces, which are much weaker. When nonpolar solutes interact with nonpolar solvents, dispersion forces between them are similar in strength, so dissolving is energetically favorable. This explains why oil dissolves in hexane—both are nonpolar and interact through the same type of forces.
However, polar solvents cannot dissolve nonpolar substances easily. Water molecules strongly attract each other through hydrogen bonding, and breaking these interactions requires considerable energy. Dispersion forces from a nonpolar solute are far too weak to compensate, so the nonpolar substance stays separate. This is why oil and water do not mix: the energy cost of disrupting water’s strong hydrogen-bond network is not offset by the weak attractions to oil molecules.
Nonpolar solvents also cannot dissolve polar solutes because they cannot stabilize charged or strongly polar particles. Without strong solute–solvent interactions, polar molecules remain clustered together instead of dispersing.
Thus, solubility depends on whether the solute and solvent can form intermolecular interactions strong enough to make dissolving energetically favorable. Polar dissolves polar; nonpolar dissolves nonpolar—because the forces involved must match in strength.
Frequently Asked Questions
Why can alcohol dissolve both polar and nonpolar substances?
Alcohols have a polar -OH group and a nonpolar carbon chain, allowing them to interact with both types of substances to some extent.
Do all polar substances dissolve in water?
No. Very large or heavily nonpolar molecules may not dissolve even if they contain polar groups.
Why does temperature affect solubility?
Temperature changes kinetic energy, which can help overcome intermolecular forces that resist dissolving.
RevisionDojo Call to Action
Want solubility and intermolecular forces to finally make perfect sense? RevisionDojo helps IB Chemistry students build deep conceptual mastery with clear, intuitive explanations.
