Why do some molecules violate the octet rule?
Some molecules violate the octet rule because certain atoms either lack enough electrons to complete an octet, have access to empty orbitals that allow more than eight electrons, or form structures that contain an odd number of electrons. The octet rule is a useful guideline for many main-group elements, but it does not apply universally because atoms differ in size, electron availability and orbital capacity.
One reason for octet violations is the presence of electron-deficient atoms. Elements such as boron and beryllium often form compounds with fewer than eight electrons in their valence shells. For example, BF₃ leaves boron with only six valence electrons. These atoms are small and lack the electronegativity needed to attract enough electron density from surrounding atoms, making incomplete octets more stable than forcing additional bonding.
Another reason is expanded valence shells, which occur in atoms in period 3 or higher. These elements have access to empty d orbitals that allow them to accommodate more than eight electrons. Phosphorus, sulfur and chlorine routinely form expanded-octet compounds such as PCl₅, SF₆ or ClF₃. In these molecules, placing more than eight electrons around the central atom reduces electron repulsion and increases stability, directly contradicting the octet rule but following quantum principles.
A third cause involves molecules containing odd numbers of electrons, known as radicals. For example, NO and NO₂ have unpaired electrons that make achieving a full octet impossible. Instead of forcing an unstable arrangement, these molecules adopt the structure that minimizes electron–electron repulsion even if it means breaking the octet guideline. These species are often reactive because the unpaired electron creates instability.
Octet violations can also reflect formal charge minimization. Sometimes, insisting on an octet leads to unreasonable or highly unstable formal charges. Allowing an expanded or incomplete octet often produces a more realistic and energetically favorable Lewis structure.
Overall, the octet rule is a helpful heuristic, but real chemical systems prioritize energy minimization and orbital availability. When the octet arrangement conflicts with these factors, atoms naturally adopt configurations that deviate from the rule.
Frequently Asked Questions
Do transition metals follow the octet rule?
No. Their bonding behavior is dominated by d-orbitals, making the octet rule largely irrelevant.
Are octet-rule exceptions rare?
Not at all. Many common molecules—including BF₃, SF₆ and NO—violate it.
Is violating the octet rule unstable?
Not necessarily. Some of the most stable molecules involve expanded or incomplete octets.
RevisionDojo Call to Action
Want bonding exceptions explained simply and clearly? RevisionDojo helps IB Chemistry students master exceptions, patterns and underlying principles without confusion.
