Why do acids donate protons while bases accept them?
Acids donate protons and bases accept them because of the way their molecular structures influence electron distribution and stability. In the Brønsted–Lowry acid–base model, an acid is a proton donor and a base is a proton acceptor. A proton (H⁺) has no electrons of its own, so it can only attach to species with available electron pairs. Acids, on the other hand, have hydrogen atoms bonded in ways that make them capable of releasing H⁺ when placed in a suitable environment.
Acids donate protons because the bond between hydrogen and the rest of the molecule is polarized, meaning the hydrogen carries a partial positive charge. This makes it easier for the proton to detach. For example, in HCl, the electronegativity difference between hydrogen and chlorine pulls electron density toward chlorine. The hydrogen becomes electron-poor, making the H–Cl bond easy to break and the proton easy to donate.
Bases accept protons because they contain lone pairs of electrons, which attract and stabilize H⁺. Species like OH⁻, NH₃ and carbonate ions have regions of high electron density that can bond to a proton and form a stable new species. Bonding with a proton lowers the energy of the system, making proton acceptance favorable.
The behavior of acids and bases also depends on the stability of the species formed after the proton transfer. A strong acid forms a very stable conjugate base because losing a proton does not significantly destabilize the molecule. Likewise, a strong base forms a stable conjugate acid when it accepts a proton.
Water provides an excellent example of both behaviors. Because it has lone pairs, it can accept a proton and act as a base. But because its O–H bonds are polarized, it can also donate a proton and act as an acid. Its amphiprotic nature shows that proton transfer ultimately depends on electron availability and molecular stability.
Ultimately, acids donate protons because their structures make hydrogen atoms easy to release as H⁺, while bases accept protons because they possess electron pairs capable of stabilizing those protons.
Frequently Asked Questions
Why is H⁺ so reactive?
Because it has no electrons and seeks electron density, making it strongly attracted to bases.
Do all acids contain hydrogen?
Yes. A proton donor must supply H⁺, so all acids contain hydrogen atoms.
Can one molecule act as both an acid and a base?
Yes. Amphiprotic species like water can donate or accept protons depending on conditions.
RevisionDojo Call to Action
Want acids, bases, conjugate pairs and pH to finally make sense? RevisionDojo teaches acid–base chemistry with clear logic so you can approach every IB question confidently.
