Economics International Baccalaureate (IB) Practice Question: 1. Explain how the imposition of an ad-valorem tax on a good or service can correct market failure arising from negative...

Answers may include:

Definitions

1. Ad-valorem Tax: A tax based on the value of a good or service, usually expressed as a percentage.
2. Market Failure: Occurs when firms fail to efficiently allocate the resources within an economy.
3. Negative Consumption Externalities : Costs suffered by a third party as a result of an economic transaction, where the consumer's consumption imposes costs on others.

Diagram

Supply and demand diagram showing the imposition of an ad-valorem tax.

-  Initially, the market equilibrium is at the intersection of MPB and MPC, leading to overconsumption.
	- The ad-valorem tax shifts the supply curve from S to S+Tax, increasing the price and reducing quantity.
	- The new equilibrium reflects a reduction in the welfare loss triangle, indicating a more socially efficient outcome.

Explanation

• Understanding Market Failure:

  • Negative externalities of consumption occur when the consumption of a good imposes external costs on third parties, leading to overconsumption.
  • This results in a divergence between the marginal private benefit (MPB) and the marginal social benefit (MSB).

• Role of Ad-valorem Tax:

  • An ad-valorem tax increases the price of the good, effectively internalizing the external cost.
  • The tax shifts the supply curve upwards (or leftwards), reflecting the additional cost imposed by the tax.

• Correcting Market Failure:

  • The new equilibrium, post-tax, reduces the quantity consumed to a level closer to the social optimum.
  • The tax reduces the welfare loss by decreasing overconsumption, aligning MPB with MSB at the new equilibrium.

Answers may include:

Definition

1. Carbon Tax: A carbon tax is a tax which is imposed on per unit of carbon emitted.
2. Externality: The spillover effects on third parties, due to actions of consumer or producers.

Economic Theory

• Market Failure and Externalities:
  • Pollution is a negative externality where the social cost exceeds the private cost.
  • Carbon taxes aim to internalize this externality by making polluters pay for the environmental damage they cause.
• Mechanism of Carbon Tax:
  • A carbon tax increases the cost of production for goods that emit carbon, shifting the supply curve leftward.
  • This leads to a higher equilibrium price and a lower equilibrium quantity, reducing consumption and production of carbon-intensive goods.
• Incentives for Innovation:
  • By increasing the cost of carbon emissions, firms are incentivized to innovate and invest in cleaner technologies to reduce their tax burden.

Diagram

• Illustrate the imposition of a carbon tax, showing the leftward shift of the supply curve, leading to a higher price and lower quantity.
• The diagram should indicate the reduction in quantity and the new equilibrium price, highlighting the internalization of the externality.

Evaluation

• Stakeholders:
  • Consumers: Face higher prices for carbon-intensive goods, potentially reducing disposable income.
  • Producers: May incur higher production costs, leading to reduced profits unless they innovate.
  • Government: Gains revenue from the tax, which can be used for environmental projects or to subsidize green technologies.
• Long-run vs. Short-run:
  • Short-run: Immediate reduction in carbon emissions due to higher prices.
  • Long-run: Potential for significant technological advancements and shifts towards sustainable practices.
• Advantages vs. Disadvantages:
  • Advantages: Provides a clear economic signal to reduce emissions, generates government revenue, and encourages innovation.
  • Disadvantages: Can be regressive, disproportionately affecting lower-income households; may lead to carbon leakage if industries relocate to countries with no carbon tax.
• Real-world Example:
  • Sweden: Implemented a carbon tax in 1991, leading to a 25% reduction in carbon emissions by 2018 while maintaining economic growth. The tax rate was approximately $127 per ton of CO2 in 2020.
  • Evaluation: Sweden's example shows that carbon taxes can be effective in reducing emissions without harming economic growth, but the success depends on the tax rate and complementary policies.

Conclusion

• Carbon taxes can effectively reduce pollution if set at an appropriate level and complemented by other policies.
• The impact on stakeholders varies, necessitating measures to mitigate adverse effects on low-income groups.
• Real-world examples like Sweden demonstrate the potential for carbon taxes to drive significant environmental and economic benefits.