Question
HLPaper 1
1.[15]
Using real-world examples, discuss the view that deflation is more harmful than inflation.
Verified
Solution
Answers may include:
Definition
- Deflation: A sustained decrease in the general price level of goods and services in an economy over time, typically indicated by a negative inflation rate.
- Inflation: A sustained increase in the general price level of goods and services in an economy over a period of time.
Economic Theory
- Deflation:
- Leads to decreased consumer spending as people anticipate lower prices in the future, reducing aggregate demand.
- Increases the real value of debt, making it more expensive for borrowers to repay, potentially leading to higher default rates.
- Can result in a deflationary spiral, where reduced spending leads to lower production, job losses, and further decreases in demand.
- Inflation:
- Moderate inflation can stimulate spending and investment as consumers and businesses act before prices rise further.
- High inflation erodes purchasing power, leading to uncertainty and potential hyperinflation if unchecked.
- Central banks often target a low and stable inflation rate to promote economic stability.
- Additional Theory:
- The Phillips Curve suggests a short-run trade-off between inflation and unemployment, indicating that some inflation may reduce unemployment.
Diagram
- AD-AS Model:
-
Show a leftward shift in the Aggregate Demand (AD) curve to illustrate deflation, leading to lower price levels and output.
-
Show a rightward shift in the AD curve to illustrate inflation, leading to higher price levels and output.
-
Indicate equilibrium points and changes in real GDP and price levels.
-
Evaluation
- Stakeholders:
- Consumers: Deflation benefits savers but harms borrowers; inflation erodes savings but can reduce real debt burdens.
- Businesses: Deflation can lead to lower revenues and profits, while moderate inflation can encourage investment.
- Government: Deflation can increase the real burden of public debt, while inflation can reduce it but may require tighter monetary policy.
- Long-run vs. Short-run:
- In the short run, deflation can lead to economic stagnation, while moderate inflation can boost growth.
- In the long run, persistent deflation can lead to a prolonged recession, while high inflation can destabilize the economy.
- Advantages vs. Disadvantages:
- Deflation: Advantageous for consumers in terms of lower prices but detrimental to economic growth and employment.
- Inflation: Moderate inflation can support growth, but high inflation can lead to uncertainty and reduced purchasing power.
- Prioritize:
- Real-world example: Japan's "Lost Decade" (1990s) illustrates the harmful effects of deflation, with stagnant growth and increased debt burdens.
- Use data: Japan's GDP growth averaged around 1% during the 1990s, with persistent deflationary pressures.
- Compare with moderate inflation targets (e.g., 2% by central banks) that aim to balance growth and price stability.
Conclusion
- Deflation is generally more harmful than moderate inflation due to its potential to create a deflationary spiral and economic stagnation.
- Moderate inflation can be beneficial for economic growth, but high inflation poses risks to economic stability.
- Policymakers should aim for price stability to avoid the extremes of both deflation and high inflation.
2.[10]
Explain the concept of cost-push inflation.
Verified
Solution
Answers may include:
Definitions
- Cost-Push Inflation: A type of inflation caused by rising production costs, such as higher wages or input prices, which reduce aggregate supply and push the price level up.
- Aggregate Supply (AS): The total output produced in an economy at all possible price levels, over a specific time period, ceteris paribus.
- Inflation: A sustained increase in the general price level of goods and services in an economy over a period of time.
Diagram
- Diagram: Aggregate Supply and Aggregate Demand (AS-AD) Model
- Indication: The diagram should show a leftward shift of the Aggregate Supply (AS) curve, leading to a higher price level and a lower quantity of output.
- Indication: The diagram should show a leftward shift of the Aggregate Supply (AS) curve, leading to a higher price level and a lower quantity of output.
Explanation
-
Understanding Cost-Push Inflation:
- Cost-push inflation occurs when the costs of production increase, causing firms to raise prices to maintain profit margins.
- Common causes include rising wages, increased prices of raw materials, and higher taxes on production.
-
Diagram Explanation:
- Start with the AS-AD model in equilibrium.
- Illustrate a leftward shift of the AS curve due to increased production costs.
- Show how this shift leads to a higher price level (inflation) and a lower level of real output.
-
Step-by-Step Inductive Reasoning:
- Initial Equilibrium: Begin with the economy at an initial equilibrium where AD intersects AS at a certain price level and output.
- Increase in Production Costs: Explain how an increase in costs (e.g., wages, raw materials) shifts the AS curve leftward.
- Impact on Price Level and Output: Describe how this shift results in a higher price level (P1 to P2) and a decrease in real output (Y1 to Y2).
- Connection to Inflation: Link the higher price level to the concept of inflation, emphasizing that this is due to cost-push factors rather than demand-pull factors.
-
Additional Explanation:
- Wage-Price Spiral: Discuss how cost-push inflation can lead to a wage-price spiral, where higher prices lead to demands for higher wages, further increasing production costs and perpetuating inflation.
- Policy Implications: Briefly mention potential policy responses, such as supply-side policies aimed at increasing productivity or reducing production costs.