IB World Religions 3.2.1. Rites of Passage and the Seven Sacraments Across the Denominations Notes
Previous
Next
3.2.1. Rites of Passage and the Seven Sacraments Across the Denominations
Rites of passage and sacraments
A rite of passage is a ceremony marking a person's move from one stage of life to the next, and the Christian examples run from birth to burial.
Christians mark birth, entry into the community, adult commitment, marriage, ordination, serious illness and death, though no two denominations treat all of these the same way.
Roman Catholic and Eastern Orthodox churches count seven sacraments: baptism, confirmation or chrismation, Eucharist, reconciliation, anointing of the sick, marriage and holy orders.
The number was fixed in the West by Peter Lombard in the twelfth century and confirmed by the Council of Trent, so the list is much later than the rites it collects.
Most Protestant churches recognize only baptism and the Lord's Supper as instituted by Christ, acknowledging the other five as practices of the wider Church while emphasizing few or none.
The two categories cut across each other. A funeral is a major rite of passage in every church and a sacrament in none, while holy orders is one most Christians never receive.
Definition
Rite of passage means a ceremony marking a move from one stage of life to the next.
The Christian examples run from birth rites to funerals.
Some are counted as sacraments and some are not.
The rite is public, so the community registers the change as well as the person.
Note
The words sacrament and ordinance mark a real disagreement.
Sacrament implies that God acts through the sign itself.
Ordinance implies obedience to a command of Christ.
Churches using the second word usually stress the faith of the believer instead.
Infant baptism and dedication
Baptism is the rite of entry into the Church, using water and the formula from Matthew 28, in the name of the Father and of the Son and of the Holy Spirit.
Most Christians in the world are baptized as infants, a practice shared by Catholic, Orthodox, Anglican, Lutheran, Methodist and Reformed churches.
The reasons given are that baptism deals with original sin, that it parallels circumcision as a covenant sign, and that grace comes before any decision a child could make.
Godparents or sponsors answer on the child's behalf and promise to see the child raised in the faith, and the child confirms those promises later.
Orthodox infants are immersed three times, then chrismated with myron and given communion at the same service, so all three rites of initiation happen at once.
Western practice normally pours water over the head at a font, and the priest anoints the child with chrism, gives a white garment and lights a candle from the paschal candle.
Baptist, Pentecostal and many independent churches hold a dedication instead, in which parents present the child and the congregation prays, with no water and no claim that it is baptism.
Definition
Baptism is the rite of entry into the Christian Church.
It uses water and the Trinitarian formula from Matthew 28.
Most churches baptize infants, and some baptize only those who profess faith.
Nearly all churches recognize one baptism, whenever in life it was received.
Believer's baptism
Believer's baptism is baptism given only to someone old enough to profess faith, and the churches that practise it hold that a rite of entry needs a decision.
The position appeared with the Anabaptists of the sixteenth century, persecuted by Catholic and Protestant authorities alike for baptizing adults a second time.
Baptists, Pentecostals, the Churches of Christ, the Brethren and most independent evangelical churches follow it today.
The candidate is normally fully immersed, in a baptistery built into the floor of the church, or else in a river, a lake or a swimming pool.
A spoken testimony often comes first, so the congregation hears why the candidate is asking for baptism before the immersion itself.
Churches differ over age. Many will baptize a child of ten or eleven who asks, others wait longer, and the phrase age of accountability covers the judgement involved.
Common Mistake
The dispute is often described as immersion against sprinkling.
That is the visible difference rather than the disagreement.
The question is whether baptism is given to infants or only to professing believers.
Some churches that baptize infants immerse them, the Orthodox among them.
The creeds confess one baptism, which is why rebaptism is the sensitive issue.
Confirmation, chrismation and communion
Confirmation completes Christian initiation for those baptized as infants, and the candidate takes on the promises that were made for them.
In Eastern Orthodox practice the equivalent is chrismation, anointing with myron consecrated by a patriarch, given immediately after baptism in infancy rather than years later.
The Western sequence separates the two, and a Roman Catholic is normally confirmed by a bishop between about seven and sixteen, with a sponsor and often a chosen saint's name.
First communion in the West usually comes at around seven or eight after a course of preparation, and it is a significant family occasion with photographs and gifts.
Anglicans are confirmed by a bishop and were traditionally admitted to communion afterwards, though many dioceses now admit children earlier.
Lutheran and Reformed churches confirm in the teenage years after a course of catechism, treating it as a public profession rather than as a sacrament.
Churches practising believer's baptism have no confirmation at all, since the baptism itself already carries the profession of faith.
Definition
Confirmation completes Christian initiation for those baptized as infants.
The Eastern equivalent is chrismation, anointing with myron.
Catholic and Anglican confirmation is normally given by a bishop.
Protestant churches that keep it treat it as a public profession of faith.
Confession, anointing and orders
The sacrament of reconciliation, also called penance or confession, restores a baptized person after serious sin, and Catholic teaching requires contrition, confession and a penance before absolution.
Catholic confession is heard by a priest in a confessional or a reconciliation room, and the seal of the confessional binds the priest to absolute secrecy.
Orthodox confession is made standing before an icon of Christ, with the priest beside the penitent as a witness rather than opposite them as a judge.
Anglican practice is summarized in a well known formula about private confession, that all may, none must, and some should.
Anointing of the sick uses blessed oil and prayer, following James 5, and the Catholic Church renamed it from extreme unction at the Second Vatican Council to stress healing rather than the deathbed.
Orthodox churches celebrate the same rite as euchelaion, often for a whole congregation in Holy Week, so it is not reserved for the dying.
Holy orders ordains deacons, priests and bishops by prayer and the laying on of hands, and Catholic, Orthodox and Anglican churches keep that threefold order while others ordain ministers, elders or pastors.
Definition
Absolution is the declaration of God's forgiveness pronounced over a penitent.
Catholic and Orthodox churches reserve it to a priest or a bishop.
Catholic teaching requires contrition, confession and a penance before it is given.
Most Protestant churches use a general absolution in public worship instead.
Example
A Catholic parish usually lists confession times on a Saturday afternoon.
The penitent may kneel behind a screen or sit facing the priest.
The penance given is normally a short prayer or a specific act of restitution.
Marriage and funeral rites
Marriage is a sacrament for Catholic and Orthodox Christians and a covenant blessed by the church for most Protestants, and the difference shows in who is said to perform it.
In Roman Catholic teaching the couple are the ministers of the sacrament and the priest is the Church's witness, which is why consent freely given is the heart of the rite.
Orthodox weddings have no exchange of vows at all. The couple are crowned with wreaths or metal crowns and led three times around the table in the dance of Isaiah.
Protestant weddings centre on vows, the giving of rings, a reading such as 1 Corinthians 13, and a blessing pronounced by the minister.
Churches differ sharply over remarriage after divorce. Catholic teaching permits it only after an annulment, Orthodox churches allow a second and third marriage with a penitential rite, and most Protestants decide case by case.
Funerals move from a service to a committal, and the forms differ: a requiem Mass in Catholic practice, the panikhida and memorial services at set intervals in Orthodox practice, and a service of thanksgiving in many Protestant churches.
What is done over the body is much the same everywhere. The dead are commended to God and the mourners are addressed with the resurrection hope, which is why funerals carry so much doctrine.
Active recall
Name the seven sacraments and say which two most Protestant churches keep.
Give two reasons churches offer for baptizing infants.
What is the real point at issue between infant and believer's baptism?
How does Orthodox initiation differ in sequence from Western practice?
Who are the ministers of marriage in Catholic teaching, and what replaces vows in an Orthodox wedding?