Domestic policies: social policies
Education
- When Lenin and the Bolsheviks seized power in 1917, their radical vision aimed to dismantle the existing bourgeois educational framework, which they viewed as elitist and disconnected from proletarian needs.
- This led to a brief but dramatic rejection of traditional academic disciplines and methodologies: textbooks were discarded, formal examinations abolished, and schools either closed or operated on a severely limited basis.
- The Bolsheviks promoted practical, vocational training over theoretical knowledge, emphasizing skills that could directly serve the revolutionary economy.
- By the time Stalin consolidated power in the late 1920s and 1930s, there was a clear shift in priorities. Stalin recognized that modernizing the Soviet Union required a literate, disciplined population capable of supporting industrialization.
- Unlike the Bolshevik period of experimentation, Stalin’s education policies reinstated rigorous standards, formal curricula, and state control to ensure a consistent ideological and practical training of youth.
- Stalin’s education system included:
- Compulsory schooling for ten years: This was a major expansion of educational access aimed at eradicating illiteracy.
- A core curriculum: Subjects such as reading, writing, mathematics, science, history, geography, Russian language, and Marxist theory were standardized across schools.
- State-prescribed textbooks and exams: These ensured ideological conformity and uniformity in education.
- School discipline and regulations: Uniforms, homework, and controlled classroom behavior were introduced to foster order and a work ethic mirroring industrial labor discipline.
- Fees for upper secondary education (ages 15-18): Although this appeared contradictory to egalitarian ideals, it was justified as selection by merit rather than class, with scholarships available to support gifted students regardless of background.
- The results of these reforms were notable: school attendance more than doubled between 1929 and 1940, with near-universal schooling in urban areas and a sharp rise in literacy rates from 51% to 88%.
- The Soviet state effectively transformed its population into a more educated workforce, crucial for the ambitious Five-Year Plans.
- Despite these achievements, the system remained highly selective and served the interests of the state’s industrial and ideological goals rather than purely educational advancement.
- University education and academic research were subordinated to political control, epitomized by the 1935 government takeover of the Academy of Sciences. Intellectual freedom was severely curtailed, with historians and scientists expected to produce politically acceptable work.
- One infamous example was the Lysenko affair, where Trofim Lysenko, backed by Stalin, rejected established genetic science in favor of pseudo-scientific agricultural claims. This not only damaged Soviet biology but contributed to agricultural failures and famines, illustrating the dangers of politicizing science.
The Lysenko Affair
- It was a major scientific and political controversy in the Soviet Union, centered around the rise of Trofim Lysenko and his rejection of Mendelian genetics in favor of a pseudo-scientific theory known as Lysenkoism.
- Emerging in the 1930s and peaking under Stalin’s patronage in the late 1940s, Lysenko claimed that environmental factors could directly alter the heredity of plants, a view aligning with Marxist ideology that emphasized the transformative power of the environment over innate qualities.
- Lysenko rejected the concept of genes, calling them a "bourgeois abstraction," and instead advocated for vernalization, a process of artificially stimulating plant growth by cold treatment.
- With Stalin’s support, Lysenko rose to power within Soviet scientific institutions. In 1948, the Soviet Academy of Agricultural Sciences officially denounced Mendelian genetics, effectively outlawing it in favor of Lysenko’s theories.
- Scientists who opposed Lysenkoism, including leading geneticists like Nikolai Vavilov, were silenced, imprisoned, or executed. Vavilov himself died in prison in 1943. The suppression of genetic science significantly damaged Soviet agricultural productivity and retarded biological research for decades.
- If you are working with Mao as an alternative case for Authoritarian States, compare the Lysenko Affair with the details of the Great Leap Forward, another example where science and pseudo science served political aims.
Health
- From Lenin’s early decree establishing the People’s Commissariat of Health in 1918, the Soviet government aspired to provide universal, free healthcare. Yet, chronic resource shortages, political upheavals, and economic disruptions severely limited these ambitions during Stalin’s rule.
- The Civil War and subsequent famines (most notably the catastrophic 1930s famine caused by forced collectivization) overwhelmed the fragile healthcare infrastructure, particularly in Ukraine and Kazakhstan, where medical services were unable to cope with widespread malnutrition and disease.
- While certain improvements occurred in less affected regions, such as an increase in trained medical personnel and specialized facilities like tuberculosis sanatoria and maternity clinics, these advances disproportionately benefited the political elite and key workers rather than the general population.
- The state’s emphasis on industrial output and rapid urbanization often took precedence over public health concerns, exemplified by regimented childcare policies that prioritized factory schedules over maternal and child welfare.
- Overcrowded and inadequate housing in industrial cities created further health challenges, with multiple families sharing cramped apartments and limited sanitation facilities.
- These conditions facilitated the spread of infectious diseases and lowered overall living standards, although not necessarily increasing mortality rates dramatically.
- The impact of World War II was devastating. German occupation and sieges caused mass starvation, and rationing severely restricted food availability across the USSR. More than six million civilians died from starvation alone.
- Post-war recovery efforts prioritized industrial and military rebuilding, with health budgets declining and living conditions worsening for many workers. The continued scarcity of housing, food, and medical supplies meant that by Stalin’s death in 1953, the Soviet working class faced harsher living and health conditions than at almost any time in Soviet history.
Health under Stalin
- Some historians argue that Soviet health policy under Stalin saw significant improvements, particularly in terms of access and infrastructure.The regime expanded the number of hospitals, clinics, and trained medical personnel during the 1930s and postwar years.
- Mortality rates fell during the Second Five-Year Plan, and there were advances in combating infectious diseases such as malaria and typhus.
- Soviet life expectancy increased from approximately 44 in the 1920s to over 50 by the late 1930s, suggesting some success in public health campaigns.
- For many, especially in urban centers, state-sponsored medical care became more reliable and accessible, contributing to the regime's claim of building a socialist welfare system.
- In contrast, other historians emphasize the limits and contradictions of Stalinist health policy. While healthcare services expanded, they remained deeply politicized and unevenly distributed.
- Rural areas were underfunded, and access to care was often contingent on one’s political reliability or status within the party.
- Moreover, the politicization of science undermined medical research and practice.
Youth Policies under Stalin
- Under Joseph Stalin, the Soviet state saw youth as a crucial demographic for consolidating socialism and perpetuating loyalty to the regime.
- Youth policies were designed to ideologically mold Soviet children and adolescents into obedient, disciplined citizens committed to Stalinism, collectivism, and atheism.
- One of the key instruments for shaping youth was the Komsomol (All-Union Leninist Young Communist League), which targeted those aged 14 to 28. Membership, while formally voluntary, became essential for educational and professional advancement.
- By 1941, the organization had over 10 million members. Komsomol activities were not only ideological (promoting Marxist-Leninist doctrine and cult of personality) but also involved youth in large-scale projects like collectivization and industrialization, especially during the Five-Year Plans.
- For children aged 9 to 14, the Young Pioneers served as a preparatory group for eventual Komsomol membership. The Pioneers emphasized loyalty to Stalin, obedience to authority, and denunciation of "enemies of the people," including family members.
- The Komsomol and the Young Pioneers were both Soviet youth organizations, but they were not the same.
- Young Pioneers was for children aged 9 to 14. It focused on basic ideological education, patriotism, and collective behavior.
- They organized summer camps, parades, school-based activities, and commemorations of Communist heroes. They were less politically intense, often compared to scouting movements in the West—but with clear ideological content.
- The Komsomol (All-Union Leninist Young Communist League) was for youth aged 14 to 28. It acted as a direct arm of the Communist Party.Its members participated in party campaigns, enforced labor discipline, and were mobilized for industrial projects, military training, and wartime resistance.
- Functioned as a recruiting ground for future Party members and leaders. Komsomol members were considered politically mature and were expected to implement and police Stalinist ideology, acting as local enforcers and ideological agents.
- School curricula were heavily politicized, and textbooks were rewritten to reflect Stalinist ideology, erasing or distorting the roles of figures like Trotsky and Bukharin.
- Education was another cornerstone of youth policy. The 1930s saw a significant expansion in literacy and universal primary education, which the regime touted as a major socialist achievement.
- Teachers became political agents, and deviation from the approved curriculum could lead to arrest. Schooling was not merely about learning but about producing the "Homo Sovieticus," characterized by devotion to state and party.
- Stalin’s youth policies also emphasized militarization and discipline. From the mid-1930s, both Pioneers and Komsomol organizations incorporated paramilitary training. The state encouraged athleticism, physical strength, and readiness for defense, partly in preparation for looming war.
- During the Great Patriotic War, the Komsomol was crucial in mobilizing Soviet youth for military and industrial service. Over 5 million Komsomol members volunteered for frontline service in the early months of the war.
- Many were deployed in high-risk roles, such as sappers, partisans, and scouts.
- Komsomol battalions were especially active in resisting German occupation in Ukraine and Belarus, where youth were trained in sabotage and espionage.
- Many Soviet youths embraced their roles enthusiastically, genuinely believing in the socialist mission. However, others resisted passively, with non-conformist behaviors such as adopting Western fashion, listening to jazz, or engaging in private religious practices, activities the regime classified as "hooliganism" or ideological deviance.
- Sheila Fitzpatrick notes that while many youths conformed outwardly, some privately mocked official slogans or avoided participation in state rituals. A small number joined underground anti-Stalinist circles, though such actions were dangerous and rare due to the pervasive surveillance by the NKVD.


