Differences Between Soils Rich in Sand, Silt, or Clay
Particle Size and Composition
- Soils contain mineral particles of three size classes.
- Sand is the largest particle, typically 0.05 to 2 mm in diameter.
- Silt is intermediate in size and feels smooth or flour-like.
- Clay is the smallest particle, often less than 0.002 mm in diameter.
- Sand and silt are mainly made of quartz, a mineral of silicon and oxygen.
- Clay is formed from complex silicate minerals containing elements such as aluminium, magnesium or iron.
- The small size of clay particles creates very large surface areas, making them chemically reactive.
- Sand contains very few charged sites, so interacts weakly with nutrients.
- Clay contains many negatively charged sites, giving it strong attraction to nutrient cations.
Cation Exchange Capacity (CEC)
Cation-exchange capacity (CEC)
Cation-exchange capacity (CEC) is the ability of a soil to hold positively charged ions due to negatively charged particles like clays and humus.
- CEC is the ability of soil to hold positively charged ions such as calcium, magnesium and potassium.
- Sand and silt have low CEC because quartz has few negative charges.
- Clay and humus have high CEC, meaning they hold nutrients and prevent them from leaching.
- Soil colloids such as clay and humus form a clay–humus complex, the main site of chemical exchange.
- Plants absorb nutrients when root hairs release hydrogen ions that replace nutrient cations attached to clay particles.
- Soils with high CEC are generally more fertile, provided aeration allows plants to access nutrients.
- Sandy soils lose nutrients easily because cations are weakly attached and wash away in rain.
- Clay soils retain nutrients but are often difficult to cultivate because of poor aeration and waterlogging.
| Property | Sand | Silt | Clay |
|---|---|---|---|
| Particle Size | Largest (0.05–2.00 mm) | Medium (0.002–0.05 mm) | Smallest (<0.002 mm) |
| Texture | Gritty | Smooth | Sticky |
| Water Retention | Low | Moderate | High |
| Drainage | Excellent | Moderate | Poor |
| Cation-Exchange Capacity | Low | Low | High |
| Nutrient Availability | Low | Moderate | High |
| Workability | Easy to work | Moderate | Difficult |
Fertility Differences Among Soil Types
Sandy soils
- Very low nutrient retention
- Fast drainage and poor water holding
- Require organic matter to improve CEC
Silty soils
- Moderate fertility and water holding
- More nutrient retention than sand
Clay soils
- High nutrient retention due to high CEC
- Slow drainage and tendency to become waterlogged
- Can become compacted and limit root growth
- Think of sand like a basket with big holes, silt like a colander with medium holes and clay like a cloth bag with tiny pores.
- The smaller the pores, the more water and nutrients stay inside.
Determining Soil Properties
1. Soil Texture: Percent Sand, Silt and Clay
- Soil texture controls water retention, aeration and nutrient supply.
- Measured by feel tests, mechanical sieving or sedimentation.
- Classified using the soil texture triangle into categories such as loam, sandy clay, or silty clay loam.
- Texture strongly influences crop suitability, infiltration rate and erosion risk.
2. Organic Matter Content
- Organic matter improves water retention, especially in sandy soils.
- Improves drainage in clay soils by creating stable aggregates.
- Increases microbial activity, enhancing decomposition and nutrient cycling.
- Acts as a pH buffer, stabilising acidity and alkalinity.
- Boosts fertility by contributing negative charges that increase CEC.
3. Soil Moisture Content
- Soils hold varying amounts of water, influenced by rainfall, evaporation and soil structure.
- Clay retains water, often remaining cold and wet for long periods.
- Sand drains quickly, becoming dry soon after rainfall.
- Organic matter helps retain moisture, reducing rapid evaporation.
- Waterlogging reduces oxygen, slowing respiration and decomposition.
- Moisture content is often confused with infiltration rate.
- Moisture refers to how much water is present, while infiltration is how fast water enters soil.
4. Infiltration Rate
- Indicates how quickly water enters soil from the surface.
- High in sandy soils due to large pore spaces.
- Low in clay soils, which can lead to runoff and erosion.
- Compaction reduces infiltration, harming crop growth and increasing flooding risk.
- Measured using a metal ring and timed water drop tests.
Low infiltration often signals poor aeration, high bulk density, or waterlogging.
5. Bulk Density
- Bulk density is mass of dry soil per unit volume.
- Low bulk density indicates high porosity, allowing root penetration and aeration.
- High bulk density suggests compaction, hindering root growth.
- High organic matter lowers bulk density, improving soil health.
6. Soil Colour
- Black soils indicate high humus content.
- Red soils contain well-aerated iron compounds.
- Yellow soils contain hydrated iron compounds.
- Grey or blue soils indicate poor drainage, common in gleyed soils.
- White crusts signify salinization, often from evaporation in dry regions.
- Colour measured using the Munsell colour chart for standardization.
7. Soil pH
- pH influences nutrient availability, decomposition rates and microbial activity.
- Acidic soils may release toxic aluminium ions, harming plant roots.
- Weathering, rainfall and fertilizers alter pH.
- Limestone raises pH, reducing soil acidity.
- Different nutrients dissolve more readily at specific pH levels.
pH affects nearly all chemical processes in soils, including CEC, nutrient solubility, decomposition and plant uptake.
Carbon Release from Soils
- Soils store huge amounts of carbon in organic matter and humus
- Aerobic decomposition releases carbon dioxide
- Anaerobic decomposition releases methane
- Wetlands, peatlands, and rice paddies are major methane sources due to low oxygen
- Carbon release accelerates under warmer temperatures, increasing greenhouse gas emissions
Methanotrophs
Methanotrophs are microorganisms that use methane as a carbon and energy source, reducing methane emissions from soils.
Human Activities Increasing Carbon Release
- Ploughing exposes soil to oxygen, accelerating decomposition and releasing COâ‚‚
- Draining wetlands introduces oxygen, causing stored carbon to oxidize
- Intensive farming increases microbial activity and COâ‚‚ emissions
- First year of cultivation causes the highest carbon loss, especially in former grasslands
- Heavy machinery adds additional COâ‚‚ through fuel combustion
Tipping Points and Positive Feedback
- Warming causes faster decomposition, which releases more greenhouse gases
- More greenhouse gases cause further warming
- This forms a positive feedback loop
- Carbon-rich soils in tundra and boreal biomes may release methane rapidly if temperatures rise
- Methane clathrates, huge stores of methane in ice-like structures, may destabilize with warming
Wetlands cover about ten percent of Earth’s surface yet store over one third of terrestrial carbon.
- Why do clay soils have a much higher CEC than sandy soils? Explain using particle size and mineral composition.
- How does organic matter improve both sandy and clayey soils in different ways?
- Describe three soil properties that can be inferred from soil colour and explain each one.
- Why do wetlands release methane rather than carbon dioxide?
- How does ploughing contribute to soil carbon loss beyond just disturbing soil horizons?
- Explain how rising temperatures may lead to a carbon-release tipping point in frozen soils.


